Sacramento 916-357-5660 | Los Angeles 310-571-8896 | San Jose 408-467-3860

ESOP Blog

How to Determine if an ESOP Is Right for You

[fa icon="calendar"] Jun 15, 2017 11:07:57 AM / by Sheryl Bayani-Alzona

Sheryl Bayani-Alzona

How to Determine if an ESOP is Right for YouEmployee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) offer compelling advantages for business owners, companies and their employees. Out of all the business planning options out there, they stand out because of their flexibility.

ESOPs can deliver many options, benefits and possibilities. They can:

  • Lower transaction costs.
  • Facilitate cash flow in a management-led purchase of the company.
  • Provide an opportunity to reinvest the sale proceeds while deferring capital gains.
  • Deliver a ready-made market for stock.
  • Acquire shares with pre-tax cash flow.
  • Buy out a dissident or unhappy shareholder.
  • Reduce or eliminate the company’s tax liability.
  • Provide liquidity for heirs who wish to continue in the family business.
  • Establish minority discounts on family-held stock for estate planning purposes.
  • Attract financing at about 85% of the cost of conventional financing.
  • Diversify assets through minority shareholding.
  • Allow the selling owner to remain involved during the purchase, lowering the seller’s risk.
  • Attract minority-subordinated equity investors in a management-led buyout.

Many ESOP design features help the owner achieve business and personal goals. This is true whether the owner's goal is an immediate sale and exit from the company, to prepare for an ownership transition, or something in between. Look carefully at a custom-designed ESOP if these scenarios match your goals.

What to Consider When Evaluating an ESOP

To decide if an ESOP is a suitable option, consider the following:

  • Is the company in a labor- or people-intensive industry that can benefit from an ESOP’s potential to enhance productivity? ESOP-owned companies typically see a productivity boost often attributed to a boost in employee morale and sense of ownership.
  • Is the company in a cyclical industry with extreme ups and downs in stock value? If so, an ESOP may not provide the benefits employees expect and owners seek.
  • Is the company in an industry with a high risk of becoming obsolete? Could a change in technology put it out of business for reasons beyond its control? ESOPs are designed for longevity, so being a healthy company with a strong future is important.
  • Does the company have thin margins and poor cash flow that make a financed buyout impossible?
  • Does the company have enough employees and payroll to support contributions to the plan?
  • Does the company have a second level of management ready, willing and able to take over after the buyout?
  • Would the ESOP be the only retirement plan the company offers, or would a 401(k) or other plan also be available?
  • Does the owner have family members who want to take over control of the business? If so, this may preclude ESOP ownership.
  • Is the owner willing and prepared to give up some or all control of the company and share ownership with employees?

Answering these questions will help determine whether an ESOP is right for long-range business planning. One thing that makes the ESOP process helpful is that most of these questions apply to any plan. In other words, if the owner and the company cannot implement an ESOP, they likely have a lot of work to do to prepare for the future and any kind of plan. This process can help initiate that preparation.

We’re Here To Help

Now you have an idea of how to evaluate ESOP plans for business planning needs. To explore this option more deeply, you’ll need to make some additional decisions. For instance, the ESOP will need trustees, and if the trustees will be company insiders, that role needs to be explained to them. You may want to explore other financing options or know what rights ESOP shareholders have. For tax reasons, you may want to change a C corporation to an S corporation.

These are just a few of the more advanced issues we help people navigate every day. To work with the preeminent ESOP experts who can guide you to the right solution, contact Chang, Ruthenberg & Long.

Are you interested in learning more about the what ESOPs do and how they work? Take a look at our blog post outlining the employee stock ownership plan basics you need to know. 

New Call-to-action